Both drop the popcorn texture in the bag if you're using the Homax scraper or proper on to the floor. I work for Home Depot. During the paint dept. we have a tool that is manufactured specifically for removing popcorn ceilings. You attach a garbage bag into the tool and http://popcorn-ceiling-removal07264.blogzag.com/38814576/not-known-details-about-price-to-remove-popcorn-ceilings